Skip to content

Reflection: Ice Cream around Somerset Hills

July is national ice cream month, so it’s time for Mr. Local History’s look back at the history, the good fun (and some “good humor”).

NOTE: As with all Mr. Local History retrospectives, we often update the post when we learn stories and are sent photos from our community. We will continue to grow this piece as information becomes available.

Mr. Local History Project

The first official account of ice cream in the New World comes from a letter written in 1744 by a guest of Maryland’s Governor William Bladen. The first advertisement for ice cream in this country appeared in the New York Gazette on May 12, 1777, when confectioner Philip Lenzi announced that ice cream was available “almost every day.” Records–kept by a Chatham Street New York merchant–show that President George Washington spent approximately $200 for ice cream during the summer of 1790. So the history of ice cream goes all the way back to our founding fathers.

Ice cream is universal. It’s refreshingly cold with flavors galore in an industry that’s always looking for new ways to get the treat into your mouth. From creameries to ice cream trucks, the Mr. Local History project looks at the local business of ice cream over the years.

Horton’s Ice Cream was key back in 1906 in Bernardsville. Today, Penguin Ice Cream , Dairy Queen, and Baskin Robbins lead the way in Bernardsville. Credit: Bernardsville News, 1906

The Somerset Hills was a strong player in the production of ice cream ingredients, mostly dairy cream from area creameries. While outlets like Reids, Hortons and the W. E. Tunis Store created the first soda fountains in the Somerset Hills, nothing could have been better than a trip with mom and dad for a visit on a hot day.

But the process to make ice cream was difficult to keep bacteria-free. Ingredients needed to be local. Fresh cream was essential along with a sterile manufacturing process. These processes changed rapidly in the 1920s and were soon ready for regionalization for those who had a vision. In the late 1920s, two brothers from Bernardsville took a dream and began driving towards a reality.

1931: Bernardsville Gets in the Manufacturing Game

In July 1931, the Bernards Creamery Ice Cream manufacturing plant began operations on 13 Mill Lane (Street) in Bernardsville to make ice cream and sherbets, thanks to the brothers Arthur and James Looby. The ice cream was a natural extension to their already busy milk and dairy business.

Remember that back in the 1930s, freezers were still a bit of a novelty. So who remembers “dry ice”?  In response to printed invitations mailed about the opening, over 2,000 samples in Dixie Cups awaited those who visited the creamery across the street from Rudolph’s Steakhouse.

Pure ingredients were absolutely essential back in the 1930s. Issues regarding bacteria and unclean conditions led to many companies being forced to close. Bernards Creamery later became the Somerset Hills Dairy Farms. Source: Bernardsville News, 1936.

Ice Cream in the 1960s

With a mobile suburban customer base, ice cream went mainstream in a big way. All but Howard Johnson’s had roots in the Somerset Hills.

Fast forward to the 1960s and ice cream went mainstream in the Somerset Hills. All the towns except Gladstone had an outlet to get ice cream. Bernardsville led the way with most of the ice cream stores including Dairy Queen, Jerolomans, Buxtons, and Friendly’s. Basking Ridge had the Minute Man and the Corner Cupboard. And Far Hills had the Far Hills Pharmacy.

“Ah, The Dairy Queen – cruisin’ on Friday nights!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!”

Susan Hurley Carter-Withrow – Basking Ridge
The community weighed in on how much they loved the Minuteman on Route 202 and the Dairy Queen just down the road.

“Back in the day the Minute Man had the best and biggest ice cream sundaes!”

Karen Jones Potts
The first Dairy Queen in Bernardsville, July 1954 to Sept 1975. Almost to the light before the bowling alley.Dairy Queen used to be where Linders Cleaners now is… Right on that corner, crossroad of Finley & 202. (Friendly’s came Much Later, and was down a piece, just before the shopping center!) Source Bernie Frankle – Facebook
In 1963, you could grab a Dixie Cup for $.05!
August 1954, Bernardsville News – Click image to enlarge.

“The RHS cross country team would hit the B’ville DQ instead of doing our workouts when we felt like we were being ‘overworked.’ I think we were busted only once or twice by Coach Larry Smith! LOL.”

John Babyak – Basking Ridge

In Basking Ridge, the Corner Cupboard was big in Basking Ridge offering Costa’s Brand Ice Cream.

1961 Corner Cupboard Basking Ridge sold Costa's Ice Cream
The Corner Cupboard in Basking Ridge sold Costa’s Ice Cream (1961)
A 60s Aurora Good Humor slot car truck I’ve held on to. Not the fastest, but it was fun to drive.

Today: There’s a Resurrection of the Ice Cream Truck

Everyone remembers the ice cream trucks. The music, the bells, the rush to chase it down the street with a few bills you just got from your mom before you started your mad dash up the street. You hoped that some other kid was more prepared and came out screaming to stop the truck just so you could catch up. Ah, the days.

Fast forward to 2020: neighborhoods and house parties have restored offerings and new trucks rolling down your neighborhood streets. The ice cream truck goes full circle and kids again are running down the street chasing the new ice cream goodness.

Basking Ridge’s Joe Morazzo’s Vintage Ice Cream Truck Collection

Joe Morazzo and his family from Basking Ridge have been a Charter Day institution on the corner of Finley and Henry for as long as I can remember. Never passed without grabbing a creamsicle.
Credit: Brooks Betz

Joe Marazzo of Basking Ridge owns and operates Delicious Ice Cream, a company established in 1955 by his father, Al, who sold ice cream seven days a week from April to October to supplement his income as a pipe-boom and heavy-truck operator with the City of New York’s Water Department. He was the ice cream man in Marazzo’s Staten Island neighborhood and drove a 1950 Chevy ice cream truck outfitted with a refrigeration unit.

Good Humor ice cream truck sign from the 1960s.
What was your favorite?
My favorite Joe M. ice cream truck. What a beauty.
You can get ice cream at their window, or maybe you can catch their roaming ice cream truck.

And Yet Another Basking Ridge Resident To Launch the “I Scream, You Scream” Truck

Basking Ridge resident Eric Murphy has developed Scream Truck, a soft serve van that you can electronically call to your home for contact-free delivery. Eric is rolling out the concept truck in Westfield starting in mid-August 2020.


Even in a COVID 19 world, ice cream is local and we need to support them.

In addition to truck service from Basking Ridge’s Joe Marazzo and Priscilla’s Pantry, you can visit these great local ice cream eateries:

  • Ava’s Homemade Ice Cream – Basking Ridge
  • Frozen Falls – Basking Ridge
  • Penguin Ice Cream – Bernardsville
  • Dairy Queen – Bernardsville
  • Baskin Robbins – Bernardsville
  • Priscilla’s Pantry – Basking Ridge
  • Cold Stone Creamery – Bedminster
  • Baskin Robbins – Bedminster
  • Gabriel’s Fountain – Martinsville
  • Rita’s Ice Cream – Bridgewater
  • Rita’s Ice Cream – Berkeley Heights
  • Polar Cub Ice Cream Stand – Whitehouse Station (Personal Favorite 🙂 )
Sorry All. I LOVE Polar Cub! And my waistline shows it!

Post a comment! Where was your favorite Ice Cream hangout when you were growing up in the Somerset Hills?

Post a quick comment below and share with our readers.

LAST CALL: Ice Cream Tidbits

Just gotta love it! Well done! And the song? Aaaahhhhhhhhhhh……. RUNNNNNNNNNN!

July Is National Ice Cream Month. Did You Know…

  • The first ice cream parlor in America opened its doors in New York in 1776.
  • The ice cream sundae was conceived in the 1880s.
  • Vanilla ice cream reigns supreme.
  • The U.S. is second, after New Zealand, in ice cream consumption.
  • California produces the most ice cream in America.

Classic Ice Cream Videos

Do you know the history of the famed Banana Split?
A ice cream ride down memory lane.
I grew up in Westfield and the Mr. Softee truck was always down at Gumpert Field for the little league games.
Print Friendly, PDF & Email

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.