Those following the Mr. Local History Project know we love Jersey food and iconic food outlets. Along with the grand ethnic diversity comes food concoctions that have become iconic Jersey staples on the Jersey food scene over the years. One of those food concoctions started in an upstairs apartment in Newark, New Jersey way back in the 1930s and is still being made by the family business. We introduce you to Jimmy Buff’s and the Italian hot dog. We’ll start with the sandwich first, then move to how it all happened.
Announcement
Congratulations to Jimmy Buff’s for being selected as the 25th addition to the New Jersey Historic Wooden Village Collection. Now you can pronounce your love to Jimmy Buff’s with this original keepsake made exclusively for the Mr. Local History Project. Click the image to get yours while supplies last.
New Jersey is the center of the hot dog universe and the Italian hot dog from Jimmy Buff’s is the holy grail of hot dogs!
Jimmy Buff’s customer
The Italian Hot Dog
First known as the “Newark Hot Dog” the sandwich quickly caught on and became simply the “Italian Hot Dog.” The Italian hot dog (or sausage) goes inside a quarter of a large Italian pizza bread roll. Mustard is spread on the inside of the roll before adding the dog/sausage. The dog is traditionally cooked in oil and then topped with fried onions, peppers, and chip-style potatoes.
Pizza Bread – It’s like a big bagel or fat pita. It’s an Italian/American thing.”
Tommy Racioppi – Owner @ Jimmy Buff’s
Pizza bread is no longer readily available in New Jersey. With so many processes involved in creating the perfect pizza bread, we’ve always relied on our friends at Sorrento Bakery in East Hanover and Nicolo’s Italian Bakery in Montclair.
And not that you need another tie back to Newark, but there is, and it’s the critical ingredient; the hot dog. At Jimmy Buff’s, they’ve been using Best brand hotdogs from Best Provisions since Best’s started. Founded in 1938, Best Provision of Newark has been used at Jimmy Buff’s since its beginning. Back then, hot dogs ran 25 cents/pound. Started in a Newark basement, their butcher shop quickly grew and still brings their quality products to market across the country.
Best’s Provisions never shut down during the week; there is always meat to be prepared, chilled, cooked, and delivered. At the small retail counter, closed only on Sunday, all-beef hot dogs, skinless and natural casing, beckon. You know the old-timers and hot dog doyens by their coded language — W8, for the eight-to-a-pound hot dog once sold at Woolworth’s; B11 for the 11-to-a-pound dog sold at Bambergers. Best’s is a true Newark institution.
Originators of the Italian Hot Dog
Jimmy Bluff Racioppi and his Wife Mary – 1930s
We start our story by briefly introducing our two key personalities, Mary and James (Jimmy) Racioppi, pronounced “ra-CHEE-oh-pee,” of 4th Street in Newark, New Jersey. The two were married and living in an apartment with a basement in what was known as Newark’s West Side, where many fellow Italians settled prior to World War II.
This part of the story has been well documented as it was known that Jimmy Racioppi enjoyed playing cards at this home. His wife Mary would often heat up the frying skillet in the kitchen and prepare her custom-made pizza bread sandwiches on a 1/2 loaf, insides pulled out and inserted two fried hot dogs, fried onions and peppers, topped with fried sliced potatoes and mustard. It’s safe to say they haven’t changed much over the years thanks to the family’s entrepreneurial spirit.
The Jimmy Buff’s Expansion Years
The ancestors of the creator of the Italian Hot Dog continue to serve up Italian hot dogs every day. Over the years, Mike Loikith says that about twenty locations came and went as his great-grandfather and grandfather passed away, but his cousins Jimmy and Tommy still run a West Orange location and Loikith owns the Kenilworth store.
Today, there are two Jimmy Buff storefronts in New Jersey. We thought it’d be fun to note some of the notable storefronts over the years. You can see that most of the stores were opened in Essex and Union Counties and tied to the lineage of two families; the Racioppis and the Loikiths.
- 1932 – 1974 Newark—202 14th Ave. & 9th St. in Newark, NJ, in the Rutgers University Hospital section. The area was so affected by the riots of ’67 that James decided to sell the landmark store.
- 1960 – Current; West Orange – 60 Washington Street West, West Orange, New Jersey
- 2010 – Current; Kenilworth – 506 Boulevard, Kenilworth, NJ 07033 – Jimmy Buff’s of Kenilworth was originally on Michigan Avenue and then sold to Charlies Hot Dogs. Mike Loikith reopened on 506 Boulevard in Kenilworth and lived nearby in Cranford. The original 1932 Jimmy Buff’s sign hangs in the restaurant.
Jimmy Buff’s locations have closed but are not forgotten. If anyone has any photos or stories from any of the closed stores, Mr. Local History would love to hear from you.
- 1963 – 2007 Irvington – 4 Elmwood Ave & Springfield Ave. Irvington, New Jersey
- 2000 – 2012 East Hanover – Castle Ridge Plaza, 354 NJ-10, East Hanover, New Jersey 07936
- 1980-1986 – N. Plainfield – 855 Route 22W
- 1986 -2012 Scotch Plains – 2881 US Hwy 22 W Scotch Plains, NJ 07076
- Others: 1019 S. Orange Avenue, Newark (Upper Vailsburg), North Arlington – 390 Belleville Pike (Closed 1999), Pinebrook, Randolph, Prudential Center, and Caldwell.
As word spread about Jimmy Buff’s Newark hot dog creation, other players started joining the hot dog market. Buff’s didn’t stand still with a single location and began to expand their operations across what Jerseyans call central New Jersey. As many Newark residents moved west, opportunities in Essex, Morris, and Union Counties were targeted. So the obvious call was to head out west via Springfield Avenue and US Route 22 to new fertile Jersey hot dog locations where you would later find new Jimmy Buff’s locations.
Click any image to start the slideshow
At the Kenilworth location, Loikith orders about two thousand hot dogs per week and while that’s his bread and butter for the business, he also offers, cheesesteaks, chicken fingers, veggie sandwiches, and burgers too.
In W. Orange, a little-known fact; over 2,000 pounds of potatoes are cut up for Italian hot dogs every week. That’s a ton of potatoes every week!
The Jimmy ‘Buff’ Family
While the Italian hot dog originator goes to Mary & James Racioppi, we have generations of the Racioppi and Loikith families to thank.
West Orange is owned by Jimmy’s son Tom Racioppi, and Kenilworth is owned by Jimmy’s cousin Mike Loikith. Tom also owns the tent catering. Jimmy himself is retired and regulated to social media duty (his own words).
Click any image to start the slideshow
(W. Orange)
(Kenilworth)
90th Anniversary – August 1, 2022
On August 1, 2022, it was a really hot summer day in West Orange but that didn’t matter. To honor the exact opening day of the first store in Newark 90 years ago, the Racioppi family met their friends, family, and customers at their West Orange and Kenilworth locations to celebrate 90 years and four generations as a family institution. For the day, customers were allowed to purchase up to four additional sandwiches for just a nickel for each Italian hot dog purchased. Reporting back with photos, the West Orange Jimmy Buff’s had a line around the block for the entire day.
On behalf of the entire Racioppi family, we would like to thank our Grandparents for coming up with this awesome sandwich, our customers without you there is no Jimmy Buff’s. Also our incredible staff that keeps our locations running smoothly and lastly Tom and Mike for continuing in their great grandfather’s footsteps. Happy Anniversary and enjoy the 5 cent hotdogs.
Jimmy Racioppi
Favorite Story
We often ask, “What’s the best story you can remember while working in the store?” Jim took a moment and said he had a few and would get back to us. And then it hit him. Marc and Scott Kelly are some of West Orange’s most famous residents. The pride of Pleasantdale Elementary School in West Orange, Captain Marc Kelly is a naval aviator who has traveled to space four times, including voyages on the Space Shuttles Discovery and Endeavor. He was a pilot and a commander, leading his teams on missions to the International Space Station. Kelly’s twin, Scott, is currently aboard the ISS as part of a year-long study to determine whether travel to Mars may be possible (the trip to Mars would take three years). After completing the study, NASA will study both brothers to help determine the effects of extended space travel. The Kelly brothers also attended Roosevelt Middle School and graduated from Mountain High School in 1982.
“Do you remember those astronauts that went into space from West Orange years ago? Gimme a second…..ah yes; Marc and Scott Kelly, the NASA twins that were up in the space station. Well they come into the store to the counter and they handed me one of my Jimmy Buff’s t-shirts and said ‘this is for you.’ Thinking to myself why are these guys giving me my own t-shirt? Then Scott said, ‘Do you know, I took this shirt onto the ISS space station where it stayed for 256 days’ and now I want you to have it. I was blown away.
Now that’s some Jimmy Buff’s love.
Jim Racioppi
Jersey Humor and the Italian Dog
Remember that Jimmy Buff’s is a Jersey institution and it comes with all the humor, attitude, and swagger that makes Jersey, well, Jersey. You can take the person outta Jersey, but you can’t take the Jersey outta the person. That includes a Buff’s Italian hot dog. One of the best fun stories includes Orange, New Jersey’s heavyweight boxer “Two Ton Tony Galento“. It’s known that Tony Galento has the record for Italian Hot dogs eaten in one sitting – 6 doubles and 6 singles.
Media Accolades
Over the years, many television and media outlets have showcased what should be regarded as the “Official Hot Dog of Jersey.” Jimmy Buff’s has been featured on Rachel Ray, Travel Channel, Man v. Food, Diners, Drive-Ins, and Dives, Road Food, New Jersey Monthly, and Zagat’s.
Side Story – Why No Ketchup on an Italian Hot Dog
We found that the side story at Jimmy Buff’s is not uncommon at other hot dog eateries. It seems that there’s a reason why ketchup is not just a no-no on hotdogs, it’s downright bad for the sandwich.
Jimmy Faruggia, who opened Jimmy’s Red Hots in 1954 on the west side of Manhattan, believed ketchup was used to cover up the rotten taste of spoiled meat. He maintained his hot dogs were too fresh to be covered up – and Jimmy’s has never offered ketchup since it opened. Like the signs at Jimmy’s say: don’t even ask!
Apparently, no less an authority than the National Hot Dog & Sausage Council, the official trade association based in Washington, DC, agrees. It has codified the rule in its paper on “Hot Dog Etiquette and everyday guidance for eating America’s sacred food.” There, it is in black and white: “Don’t use ketchup on your hot dog after the age of 18.”
Nobody drove home the point more profoundly than Dirty Harry. In the film “Sudden Impact”, Clint Eastwood, playing San Francisco detective Harry Callahan, a.k.a. Dirty Harry, appears at a crime scene, blows his top while watching a cop munching on a hot dog:
“Nah, this stuff isn’t getting to me, the shootings, the knifings, the beatings, old ladies being bashed in the head for their social security checks… Nah, that doesn’t bother me. But you know what does bother me? You know what makes me really sick to my stomach? It’s watching you stuff your face with those hotdogs. Nobody, I mean nobody puts ketchup on a hot dog.”
Dirty Harry
Comments/ Story to Share?
Have a comment or Jimmy Buff’s story to share? There’s a comment section at the bottom of this story
MORE Jersey “Classic Foodie” Stories
