Views: 1,357 In the early 1700s, German Lutherans settled around Pluckemin and established one of the region’s first congregations. By 1715, they had built a small log church on what is the Second Watchung Mountain, known also as Pigtail Mountain, east of the village along Mount Prospect Road above Washington Valley Road. The congregation called … Continue reading The Hills Church & Cemetery & Pluckemin’s Pigtail Mountain